3.5MHz antenna, stepping motor this and that (2025/05/16)
On the use of a stepping motor for remote tuning of a tuning barycon for a 3.5 MHz Twep antenna I looked up a few things on ChatGPT. I did get some information from ChatGPT about the step IR antenna, Other information about stepping motors was almost the same as yesterday's information from JG2TST Matsui.
I asked ChatGPT about the step IR yagi antenna.
The following is a description of the stepper motor drive system used in SteppIR antennas (e.g., SteppIR 3-elec., BigIR, etc.) and its relationship to the controller:
Overview of Stepping Motor Drive of SteppIR Antenna Driving system: SteppIR typically uses bipolar stepping motors, driven by
Motor is installed in the antenna body (element base)
Controller (e.g. SDA100) is installed in the shack
4 wires A+/A-/B+/B- wired directly from shack to antenna
For this reason, many users pull 20 to 30 m of thick cable (shielded twisted pair) for motor drive.
Put the controller near the motor? →.NO In the SteppIR stock, the motor controller is located in the shack and is extended to the motor by power lines (A+/A-/B+/B-). It is not controlled by step, direction, or enable (PUL/DIR/EN) signal wires.
Is the EN/DIR/PUL system (STEP/DIR control) stable? This is a common CNC control method and is often used in motor control ICs (e.g., TMC, A4988, DM556, etc.).
Conditions for stabilization with this method:
Since STEP/DIR/EN are digital signals, they are more resistant to noise than motor power lines and can be sent over a long distance in a stable manner.
Communication distance: Stable operation at 30m (twisted pair + shield recommended)
If this method is used, the driver board should ideally be placed near the motor and only PUL/DIR/EN should be sent from the shack.
(data) item
SteppIR genuine method
STEP/DIR method (for homebrewers)
Motor Drive
Directly from the shack driver.
Driver near motor
Wiring distance
20-30m motor power line
30m signal line
Noise Effects
susceptible
Hard to receive (reinforced by twisted pair)
stability
Dependent on cable quality
High (conditional)
Homebrewing Difficulty Level
Low (genuine use)
High (driver selection and design required)
Recommended electric wire
For motor power lines
Shielded twisted pair x 2 pairs (AWG18-16)
For STEP/DIR/EN signal line
Shielded LAN cables (CAT6 STP, etc.) are acceptable
If using ZK-SMC01 and TB6600, it is much more stable to pull 30m of EN/DIR/PUL signal line than to pull 30m of A+, A-, B+, B- motor line.
Comparison items
A+, A-,B+, B- Direct drive
EN/DIR/PUL signal control
Signal type
High current, analogous
Constant current, digital
Noise Characteristics
Low (large inductive noise effect)
High (can be counteracted by twisted pair)
distance tolerance
Possible voltage drop and malfunction over long distances
More than 30m is possible (shield recommended)
stability
Dependent on cable quality
Relatively stable
Recommended configuration
ZK-SMC01 (pulse output) installed on shack side
Place the TB6600 in the immediate vicinity of the motor (in an outdoor case)
Draw 3 wires (+GND) of EN/DIR/PUL with twisted pair or STP cable (LAN cable diversion is also acceptable)